Evidence of different reproductive traits in the transisthmian sister species, Alpheus saxidomus and A-simus (Decapoda, Caridea, Alpheidae): description of the first postembryonic stage

The emergence of the Isthmus of Panama, approximately 3.0-3.5 million years ago, established two very different marine systems (the Caribbean and the eastern Pacific) and separated previously continuous marine populations. The geographic isolation of transisthmian sister species provides an excellent basis for the study of divergence and speciation processes. Here we describe the morphology of the first postembryonic stage of Alpheus saxidomus and A. simus, two rock-boring alpheids; the estimated time since divergence for this transisthmian pair ranges from 4.4-6.1 to 3-9 million years. The presence of a first zoeal stage in A. saxidomus, e.g., without pleopods and a telson with 7 + 7 setae, indicates a prolonged developmental sequence. In contrast, hatchlings of A. simus are substantially more developed and resemble juveniles. Thus, the developmental modes of A. saxidomus and A. simus are strikingly different with abbreviated, most probably direct, development in the latter species. Reduced food availability in the Caribbean compared to the Pacific coast is likely to be a possible reason for the evolution of such important differences in life history traits of the two transisthmian sister species. It is suggested that a transition from prolonged to abbreviated development evolved gradually during the estimated time since divergence; however, such a shift may have taken place within a substantially smaller time span.